The Hunt for Greenpoint’s Best Hot Toddy

This post made possible by a donation to our Writer’s Fund from Paulie Gee’s.

I drank a lot of whiskey last week on my quest to find Greenpoint’s best hot toddy. The booze guzzling was well worth the effort. I’m proud to announce Greenpoint bars are no stranger to the tasty winter treat. I found a few bangin’ toddies in this ‘hood and got a little tipsy along the way.

Before I feign food critic and rate the toddies, how about some history, in case you’ve somehow survived without toddies all winter long? Traditionally, the drink combines whiskey, boiling water and sugar or honey. Cloves, lemon and/or cinnamon may also be added. According to good ol’ Wikipedia, hot toddies were once recommended as a cure for the common cold, but the American Lung Association denounced this because alcoholic beverages cause dehydration. Yeah, whatever.

Though a seemingly simple recipe, concocting the best hot toddy is an art. You’d be surprised how disappointing a toddy can be – especially when you’re paying $8 for what tastes like hot water with lemon. Luckily, the bartenders in this neighborhood know what they’re doing and tend to be plenty generous when it comes to pouring whiskey.

Runner Up: Greenpoint Heights, 278 Nassau Avenue
Toddy: $6

Props to the hidden dive bar on the corner for having hot water ready to go upon my arrival. Also, I’m sending a virtual fist pump to the bartender for pouring half a mug-full of Evan Williams before adding the water, cinnamon stick and lemon with cloves. THIS toddy would cure a common cold. And knock you on your ass. Heights’ hot toddy isn’t trying to be anything special. It needs honey. I did like the holiday teddy bear mug, though. And I hear this place has great tacos.

Runner Up: Black Rabbit, 91 Greenpoint Avenue
Toddy: $8

First, let me point out that Black Rabbit wins for coziest, most perfect toddy ambience. Fireplace? Check. Twinkly lights? Check. This is an ideal place to escape a cold winter night. My biggest problem with their recipe is the use of scotch instead of whiskey. Huh? It wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t my favorite. Rabbit’s excessive use of lemon made the toddy too bitter for my liking. Additional ingredients include honey syrup (equal parts honey and water, boiled and cooled), Tetley’s black tea bag, cinnamon stick and a clove-studded lemon slice.

Third Place: Berry Park, 4 Berry Street
Toddy: $8

“Jameson. Fresh lemon. Honey.” That’s what the menu reads. There’s not much else to say about it. Berry Park’s toddy fits the traditional definition best. It’s simple and delicious and not trying to be fancy. It had just the right amount of each ingredient.

Second Place: Spritzenhaus, 33 Nassau Avenue
Toddy: $8

For the record, Spritzenhaus almost came in first. I lucked out with a bartender who is extremely passionate about his hot toddy making. His trick: Coat the bottom of the glass (not a mug) with lots of honey. He used Barton’s whiskey, which sounds worse than it tastes, I promise. The honey disguised it well. You can certainly request better whiskey if you prefer. Spritz’s toddy also included a lemon wedge with cloves in it and a cinnamon stick. Fireplaces and Jenga definitely added to this Greenpoint beer garden’s hot toddy perfection. Bravo, Spritzenhaus. Bravo!

WINNER: Enid’s, 560 Manhattan Avenue
Toddy: $8

Enid’s serves a perfectly whiskeyed and perfectly sweetened toddy that’s easy on the lemon (despite the use of lemon juice and a lemon wedge) and sans both cinnamon and honey. The secret ingredient that makes this toddy so goddamn delightful is…wait for it…maple syrup! In addition to its deliciousness, the hundreds of handmade snowflakes hanging from the ceiling and the still-standing-in-January Christmas tree provided the ultimate winter atmosphere. Enid’s toddy isn’t on the menu, but ask and you shall receive. Congrats, Enid’s!

The Enid’s Magic Recipe:
1 Part Maker’s Mark Bourbon
1 Part Fresh Squeezed Meyer Lemon Juice
1 Part Grade B Maple Syrup
2 Parts Boiling Water

8 Comments

  1. Sherry says:

    Though I don’t drink hot toddies, the Habitat deserves to be on this list.

    Reply
  2. deen says:

    After reading this I am craving a Hot Toddy!

    Reply
  3. Jenny says:

    Thanks for the tip, Sherry! I’ll be sure to check out Habitat’s hot toddy.

    Reply
  4. dpatrick1a says:

    Did you guys try any of the bars that where here longer than enid’s? Just curious.

    Reply
  5. Amanda says:

    Did you try Harefield Road? They have a very delicious (and super strong) no none-sense hot toddy.

    Reply
  6. arty says:

    Not exactly GP, but Cubana Social has a killer toddy– Aged Rum, Organic Chamomile Tea, Honey, Lemon Juice, Cinnamon, Cloves

    Reply
  7. BigBeug says:

    The Pencil Factory has a wicked hot toddy. I recommend trying it and then rewriting this article! :)

    Reply
  8. Pingback: Krupnik na Gorąco: the Polish Hot Toddy | Greenpointers

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *