Check out the Mary Fisher Home, Greenpoint’s 19th Century Artists’ Colony

Photo by Lucie Levine
Photo by Lucie Levine

Greenpoint’s industrial past is well known, and its emerging identity as an artist’s hub might seem like a 21st century phenomenon, but back in 1888, Greenpoint was sporting its very own artists’ colony. That year, Mary Fisher, of 71 Java Street, opened her home as the Home Hotel Association, a residence for elderly “Brain Workers.” According to the plaque marking the historic site, Fisher defined “Brain Workers” as men and women “who had labored in literature or art or any other brain profession.” The Home operated on Java Street until 1912, when it moved to two separate locations: one in Mount Vernon, NY, and another in Tenafly, New Jersey.

71 Java Street Today
71 Java Street Today

Mary Fisher was an Englishwoman inspired by the old age pensions which support the elderly in the UK. Social Security wasn’t established in the United States until 1935, so there was no public safety net for older people who had retired, or were out of work. In The Story of the Mary Fisher Home, published 1915, Fisher wrote, “I remembered that in Europe, pensions were often accorded to those who, during their lifetimes, had been of some benefit to the nation, and it seemed to me that in this country the people must do what the government failed to do, and I hoped that in time we might have a national fund for this purpose.”

Fisher appealed to notable New Yorkers for their in kind or financial support, and was well received by Fredrick Barnard, then the President of Columbia University. He introduced her to a variety of prominent and charitable New Yorkers, including Mrs. Andrew Carnegie, but not everybody believed that “brain workers” deserved philanthropic support. In fact, upon hearing the appeal, one woman said, “A home for old authors and artists! My! What a company of cranks! What will you do with them?” 

Undeterred, Fisher readied her home on Java Street for aging literati, and quite a company did arrive at her door. She writes of the aged actress who made leather doll’s shoes at 15 cents a pair, and of an elderly journalist who “had lost his grip on the New York Times, where he had been employed for many years.”

But not all of Fishers tenants were older people. There was also the Byronic young poet, dying of consumption, with his book of unpublished verses by his bedside. Fisher wrote that when he died his aunt asked, “‘Why do such poor fellows persist in writing books, when they can’t make a living? He had better be a carpenter or a plumber, and leave the rich men to write books. He couldn’t sell his poems. What was the use of writing them?'” To which the minister replied, “But it would hardly do for us to depend only on our rich men for our literature.” 

Mary Fisher saw merit in art and artists even when other didn’t, and made Greenpoint richer in spirit for it.

About Lucie Levine

Lucie Levine is the founder of Archive on Parade, a local tour and event company that aims to take New York’s fascinating history out of the archives and into the streets. She’s a Native New Yorker, licensed New York City tour guide, and freelance writer with a passion for the city’s social, political and cultural history.

2 Comments

  1. paul says:

    Geof. Cobb, you have competition! Both of you, thanks for the posts here.

    Reply
  2. Awesome coverage!!! But why no mention of the historic home being For Sale? Obviously I’m the Broker for this property, but seems relevant. 😉

    More fun facts about the Mary Fisher Home is its currently owned by the Hoffman Family — descendants of the first Dutch Colonists. I had spoken to The NY Times about a feature considering the notable history. But they only covered this as “On the Market” Sept. 10:
    ‪https://nyti.ms/2xdtsM2‬

    But The NY Times didn’t cover any of this fascinating history. But you did! And it’s amazing. Love your articles!!

    Please let me know if you’d like me to put you in touch with the Hoffman Family historian. She’d love to speak with you!

    Kind regards,
    Michael Keith Davis
    Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
    16 Year Reaident of North Brooklyn

    RECENT PRESS
    • THE REAL DEAL: Movers & Shakers
    • Curbed: Lower East Side’s Last True Artist Loft
    • The New York Times: On the Market
    • The New York Times: Peace Pentagon
    • Commercial Observer: Salons by JC Blowing into NY City

    90 Fifth Avenue, 7th Floor
    New York NY 10011
    mobile: 917-445-8500
    Compass

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *